Vegetarian Protein - Myth and Reality

Part 1 of 5: The Myth of Protein In A Vegetarian Diet

The number one question most vegetarians are asked is: "How do you get enough protein?", and the first question from people considering a vegetarian diet is "How will I get enough protein?"

The Myth of Protein is so widely accepted as fact that even vegetarians believe it! It goes like this:

1. Protein is the most important nutrient in our diet, and protein from meat, fish, poultry, milk and eggs is superior to the incomplete protein from plant sources.

2. Meat is the best protein source, and other foods have little or no protein.

3. A vegetarian diet doesn't have enough protein, and is therefore unhealthy.

Vegetarian Protein Reality

Over the last few decades, wide spread practical experience of vegetarian diet, knowledge of traditional cultures, and hundreds of health/diet studies, all tell a different story.

1. Too much protein is as harmful as too little, and is linked with shorter life expectancy, increased cancer and heart disease risk, widespread obesity and diabetes, osteoporosis, kidney stress, and bad digestion

2. High protein-diets bring about temporary weight-loss, at the expense of overall health, and people quickly regain weight once they return to a normal diet

3. A varied vegetarian diet with a balance of protein, fats & carbohydrates, and adequate calorie intake provides more than enough protein

4. Complete animal protein is not superior to complete protein from more than one plant source – they give the same result in different ways

5. Protein from plant sources doesn't include excess calories from fat, toxic residues, or an overabundance of protein, which stresses the kidneys

The Gospel According to Industrial Agriculture

Nothing in our modern human diet has been as misunderstood, and as misrepresented, as protein. It's considered by most people as the foundation of nutrition --- and essential to life. The importance of eating enough protein, primarily from animal sources, is drilled into us daily from childhood.

It's been estimated that the average person in this country eats two - six times more protein, usually from animals, than is needed for good nutrition. At it's most extreme, our protein fixation has led to the popularity of high-protein low-carb weight loss diets, condemned by doctors and nutritionists from coast to coast.

The development of factory farms and modern meat processing plants, aided by refrigeration, along with economic rail and truck shipping, made meat and dairy products widely available and affordable. The results, for our health, the environment, and world hunger, have been disastrous. Before the late 1800's most of the world didn't eat a lot of meat, or dairy, as there just wasn't that much available for ordinary people.

Except in myths of the Wild West, the average person didn't have a horse and gun to run around shooting things to eat, or a herd of cows to kill. Mostly they worked pretty hard, for not much money, and didn't have that much time.

Since the early 20th century, a meat and dairy centered diet has been heavily promoted as the answer to dietary deficiencies, the flawed logic being that since we're mammals, and our bodies are made with protein, then we need to eat mammals in order to get enough protein and maintain our bodies. That cannibalistic logic doesn't hold up under the most casual examination.

Unfortunately most of recent human history is based on flawed logic. And we tend to rewrite history about every fifty years to harmonize with the current world view.

The world would be a much kinder, healthier place today if people had gone with greens, grains and beans instead of milk and meat as the solution to dietary deficiencies. A few people did – they adopted a vegetarian diet, and their dietary protein comes mainly from plants.

"As soon as I realized that I didn't need meat to survive or to be in good health, I began to see how forlorn it all is. If only we had a different mentality about the drama of the cowboy and the range and all the rest of it. It's a very romantic notion, an entrenched part of American culture, but I've seen, for example, pigs waiting to be slaughtered, and their hysteria and panic was something I shall never forget."

Cloris Leachman

Next:  2    3    4    5

SV Articles and Reviews on Related Topics:

How Much Calories and Protein Do We Really Need?

How To Get Enough Protein In Your Vegetarian or Vegan Diet

Iron and Vegetarian Diet

Magnesium is Critically Important to Your Vegetarian Health!, by Sarah Kingsbury

'Organic Food: What Is It and Why Should We Eat It?, by Judy Kingsbury

Plant Food Protein Chart

Sample Menus For Complete Protein

The New Becoming Vegetarian by Melina & Davis - SV Review

Vegetarians, Are You Getting Enough Vitamin B12?, by Sarah Kingsbury

Water, The Holistic Health Elixir, by David Haworth

Send a link, resource, book, recipe etc. to Savvy Veg

Download Free Savvy Vegetarian Reports

Get Free Savvy Vegetarian Advice